US rare Indian head pennies for coin collectors and other buyers

HomeCoinsUnited States coinsUS penny coins

US rare Indian head pennies for coin
collectors and other buyers

FIND US INDIAN HEAD CENT COINS FOR SALE

The first successful small penny in United States coinage was the “Indian head” one cent coin, produced from 1859 until 1909. The coin’s design did not actually feature a Native American head per se; it was a portrait of lady Liberty wearing an Indian head dress. The Indian penny was made of mostly copper, with nickel added in the first few years, and zinc or tin after 1864.

The first year of the Indian head cent featured a laurel wreath on the reverse; subsequent issues changed this to an oak wreath with a shield on top. Both designs featured the phrase ONE CENT.

Indian head pennies are common collectors’ items now, and scarce and higher-grade examples are beloved cornerstones of many collections. Buyers looking for Indian head pennies should check current listings for the latest for-sale offers. In 1909, the Indian head penny gave way to the Lincoln wheat penny. 

US Indian head cent coins for sale

Currently showing our favorite 200 sales from eBay, and our favorite 1 listing from Amazon sellers. Click for shipping details and money-back guarantee info. US Indian head cent coins listings are chosen using MegaMinistore's original custom technology. We show you only the latest and best offers from safe, trusted vendors. Sales are updated and refreshed every day.

When you click a link to a merchant and make a purchase, it can result in this website earning a commission. Affiliations include, but are not limited to, eBay Partner Network. 

Showing 1 - 10 of 201

1909-1958 US Mint Wheat Penny Shot Gun Roll w/Indian Head Cent End Penny Seller Good or Better

Seller: New Pastimes ★★★★★★★★★★ 96.6% (170 ratings)
Location: United States

SUPERSAVER  ·  PRIME

$17.99

In Stock

1863 INDIAN HEAD CENT WITH DDR - WBLS- 087

Seller: coinsmart_77 ★★★★★★★★★★ 100% (45 ratings)
Location: United States

10% OFF
$615.50
$553.95 or best offer

Limited-time deal. Buy It Now Price

1896 1C Indian Head Cent PCGS PR65BN - Colorful Gem Proof in TrueView!

Seller: southcoastmetalglass ★★★★★★★★★★ 100% (947 ratings)
Location: United States

$893.99 or best offer

Buy It Now Price

1864 BRONZE NGC MS-64 RED Indian Head Cent Penny W0351

Seller: gncoin ★★★★★★★★★★ 100% (53,783 ratings)
Location: United States

$688.00 or best offer

Buy It Now Price

1886 indian head penny type 2 UNC++++

Seller: unicoins ★★★★★★★★★★ 98.8% (180 ratings)
Location: United States

$620.00 or best offer

Buy It Now Price

1906 Proof Indian Head Cent 1c NGC PF64 BN Monster Toned Incredible Blue Mirror

Seller: krystalcarrol ★★★★★★★★★★ 100% (18 ratings)
Location: United States

$799.00 or best offer

Buy It Now Price

1ST YEAR ISSUE PCGS CERTIFIED GOLD SHIELD U.S. MINT 1859 INDIAN HEAD CENT AU55

Seller: *bestcoin* ★★★★★★★★★★ 100% (6,752 ratings)
Location: United States

$599.99 or best offer

Buy It Now Price

1898 Indian Head Cent Penny Great Condition

Seller: oswgar_7
Location: United States

$750.00 or best offer

Buy It Now Price

Indiana Head Penny 1897

Seller: arcur_2085
Location: United States

$1,000.00 or best offer

Buy It Now Price

Indian head

Seller: jefwhit_4619
Location: United States

$1,000.00 or best offer

Buy It Now Price

Show
1 - 10 of 201

Browse more on MegaMinistore